Jobs, friends, and the future: What students really want
Drawing on insights from first-year economics students, Dr Anita Singh explores what students value most from their university experience, from career prospects and academic achievement to friendships and a sense of belonging. She considers how business schools can better understand student expectations and respond to their academic, professional, and social needs.
Jobs, friends, and the future: What students really want
Authors
Dr Anita Singh, PhD, MSc (Economics), MSc (HRM), SFHEA
Assessment Lead F&E| Reader in Economics, Department of Finance and Economics, Faculty of Business and Law, Manchester Metropolitan University
First-year undergraduate students want careers and community, but universities tend to focus on demonstrating the former.
University strategies and first-year students’ hopes often speak in different registers. Strategies talk of global reach, societal transformation, and contributing to human flourishing. Students may simply want a good degree, a worthwhile career, lasting friendships, and a clear explanation of how their timetable works.
Neither perspective is trivial. Universities have responsibilities beyond the individual learner, and students are making a substantial personal and financial investment. In England, higher education is increasingly judged on outcomes such as continuation, completion, and progression into work or further study (Office for Students, n.d.). When universities communicate their ambitions in broad, strategic terms while students focus on careers, friendships, and everyday experiences, a disconnect can emerge. The problem is not necessarily what universities aspire to achieve, but how they communicate those ambitions to students.
What first-year economists told me.
During induction week, I asked first-year economics students to respond anonymously to three questions on a shared Padlet wall. I analysed 151 posts and comments thematically. The sample is small and perhaps not truly representative, but it gives a useful indication of what students expect before teaching begins.
Four findings stand out:
A job is the main destination. Almost all the students who described where they hoped to be in three years named a job or career. Only two explicitly mentioned high pay.
But employment is not the whole story. Asked what they most hoped to gain from university, almost half mentioned friends or connections, experience and memories, and about one third mentioned the degree itself. Only 10% referred directly to employment.
For many, university is a default choice. Of those who explained why they enrolled, 25% described university as a fallback, whether after A-levels or because an apprenticeship was unavailable.
The subject risks fading from view. Interest in economics was the most common reason for enrolling, yet only two students named a deeper understanding of economics as their main hope.
Students want the credential and the career. They also want the social and experiential side of university that surrounds both.
These patterns are consistent with existing research. Decisions to study business and economics are shaped by family background, prior attainment, and career expectations, alongside personal interest (Black and Schofield, 2018). Students are neither purely calculating consumers nor purely curious scholars. Research describes many UK undergraduates as ambivalent, willing to assert their rights as consumers while still viewing learning as a two-way relationship. Research involving students across European countries has also found that they view higher education as preparation for work, a route to personal growth, and a means of contributing to society (Tomlinson, 2017; Brooks et al., 2021).
What universities promise
Course pages from various higher education institutions typically lead with employability: career destinations, placements, employer links, and graduate-outcome statistics. This is a legitimate and valuable offer, but it is a particular one. Success is measured largely through destinations, while friendship, belonging, and the experience of studying in a city tend to appear as atmosphere rather than evidence. This matters because friendship is not peripheral. Recent research suggests that friendships support emotional wellbeing, academic adjustment, and professional development among first-year students (Erdemir, Öztürk and Sumbas, 2025). Meaningful moments of belonging often arise in classrooms, accommodation, and social spaces, and commuter students may be particularly at risk of exclusion (Pugh, Jassi and Chambers, 2025). At the same time, paid work is increasingly common among full-time undergraduates, leaving less unstructured time for social life (Neves et al., 2025).
The gap is not the familiar one in which students want jobs and universities want learning. Both want both. The difference lies in what each side leads with and what each side measures. A graduate-outcomes percentage cannot tell an aspiring analyst how likely they are to enter the sector they have in mind, nor can it show whether they will find friendship, purpose, or intellectual excitement along the way.
What business schools can do
Four practical steps follow:
Be specific about ‘a good job’. Publish course-level destination data and typical pathways into finance, consulting, public policy, and analysis, rather than relying only on institution-wide figures.
Build friendship into the curriculum. Use structured group work, peer mentoring, and collaborative induction, rather than treating belonging as an optional extra.
Support fallback entrants early. Students who came to university after missing out on an apprenticeship may need early reassurance, clear employability routes, and accessible work-based learning.
Ask students again. Repeat the same questions with larger samples across programmes, both at the end of year one and near graduation.
Final thoughts
Students and universities broadly agree on the destination. They differ on the journey. The challenge for business school leaders is not to choose between ambition and pragmatism, but to connect them. A school can be globally ambitious and still answer the more immediate question students are asking: what will these three years give me, and who will I become along the way?
References
Black, G. and Schofield, A. L. (2018) ‘A comparative study of the determinants of future plans and expectations of business students’, Journal of Education for Business, 93(3), pp. 113–123.
Brooks, R., Gupta, A., Jayadeva, S. and Abrahams, J. (2021) ‘Students’ views about the purpose of higher education: a comparative analysis of six European countries’, Higher Education Research & Development, 40(7), pp. 1375–1389.
Erdemir, N., Öztürk, N. and Sumbas, E. (2025) ‘The role of friendship in the experiences of first year undergraduate students’, in Proceedings of the 7th International Palestra Scientific Research Congress. Skopje, 29–31 October, pp. 1013–1022.
Mainardes, E. W. and Silva, É. D. (2016) ‘Expectations of higher education students: a comparison between the perception of student and teachers’, Tertiary Education and Management, 22(2), pp. 171–188.
Neves, J., Freeman, J., Stephenson, R. and Rowan, A. (2025) Student Academic Experience Survey 2025. London: Higher Education Policy Institute and Advance HE.
Office for Students (n.d.) Student outcomes. Available at: https://www.officeforstudents.org.uk/for-providers/quality-and-standards/how-we-regulate-student-outcomes/ (Accessed: 20 October 2026).
Pugh, E., Jassi, S. and Chambers, B. (2025) ‘Mapping sense of belonging “moments” on university students’ journey’, in The Barcelona Conference on Education 2024: Official Conference Proceedings. IAFOR.
Tomlinson, M. (2017) ‘Student perceptions of themselves as “consumers” of higher education’, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 38(4), pp. 450–467.